Dear Lil Rounds
Firstly, I don’t want to admit to the world that I actually devote hours each week to watching American Idol, but you leave me no choice. I was duped — my boyfriend loves it, and I love skill-based reality television, so I tolerate it.
When you auditioned, and with your first few weeks, I instantly fell in love. You sound like some of my favorite singers, Mary J. Blige and Alicia Keys. I love them, and I love your voice, when you sing those songs. And your family is just freaking adorable.
However, in order to do well on Idol for the past couple of years, it takes more than just being a decent Karaoke singer. As odd-judge-out Kara DioGuardi has said, especially to you, you should have shown that on top of your singing chops, you have to exhibit artistry.
Translation: You shouldn’t have sang songs from black artists. Or Celine Dion, because she’s lame and boring. Everyone expects you to do that.
So, like Adam Lambert, and Allison Iraheta, and some of those other people I don’t really care about, you should have done something out of the ordinary. But you really didn’t.
And honestly, as a fellow lady of blackness, I felt for you, and I know you should just be out there, singing whatever you want to sing. Whatever suits you, just go freaking sing it and be happy. But I understand the flip side — and I appreciate singers who have a greater realm of artistry than just what they appear they’re good at.
I don’t know your life story. Perhaps you’ve had no formal musical training, so you might not be fully aware of how to actually change the full arrangement of a song, as opposed to singing a few notes differently. For example, let’s take songs from the year you and I were both born, 1984. A wonderful year. You sang “What’s Love Got To Do With It” by Tina Turner. While I love that song, and I love Tina, here’s a bunch of songs you could have twisted into your own style, that were the tops in 1984:
1. When Doves Cry, Prince
5. Against All Odds (Take A Look At Me Now), Phil Collins
13. Let’s Hear It For The Boy, Deniece Williams
15. Girls Just Want To Have Fun, Cyndi Lauper
17. Time After Time, Cyndi Lauper
23. Hold Me Now, Thompson Twins
33. I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues, Elton John
35. Borderline, Madonna
38. Here Comes The Rain Again, Eurythmics
39. Uptown Girl, Billy Joel
57. Love Is A Battlefield, Pat Benatar
64. If This Is It, Huey Lewis and The News
You couldda made those your own, Lil! You couldda!
Anyway, good luck in your career. And also, your butt is fabulous, despite your Vote for the Worst caricature.
Love,
Michelle